| 2023-2024 Dan Combs | 1983-84 William H. Sharp |
| 2022-2023 Becky Panchot | 1981-83 Donald M. Boesch |
| 2021-2022 Heather Garner | 1980-81 George H. Treaster |
| 2020-2021 Tony Miano | 1979-80 Edwin H. Bradley |
| 2019-20 Harry Peterson | 1978-79 Harold J. Paul |
| 2018-19 Becky Panchot | 1977-78 Keith R. Bishop |
| 2017-18 Becky Panchot | 1976-77 Rev. Merlin Wegener |
| 2016-17 Laddie Cross | 1975-76 Billy H. Miller |
| 2015-16 Jim Barton | 1974-75 Robert W. Dugal |
| 2013-14 Heather Garner / Jim Barton | 1973-74 Grover H. Norman |
| 2012-13 Kraig Sutherland | 1972-73 Claud E. Lovitt |
| 2011-12 Kellie Cribbs | 1971-72 A. Clayton Osman |
| 2010-11 Seth Pegram | 1970-71 John G. Hirsch |
| 2009-10 Sheila Allen | 1969-70 Vinton G. Johnson |
| 2008-09 Amanda Farrell | 1969 Norman R. Politte |
| 2007-08 Tony Miano | 1968 Ferd Repp |
| 2006-07 Sheila Allen / Keith Bishop | 1967 Rev. Fred Langsdale |
| 2005-06 Torie Young | 1966 Harry J. Sailor |
| 2004-05 Pat King | 1965 Harold F. Clark |
| 2003-04 Tom Huddleston | 1965 PJ Newell (Resigned) |
| 2002-03 Jeanette Bishop | 1964 Floyd F. Hager |
| 2001-02 Rev. David Webster | 1963 Floyd E. Becker |
| 2000-01 Tony Miano | 1962 Albert M. Forman |
| 1999-00 Floyd Becker | 1961 William C. Martin |
| 1998-99 Lynn Crites | 1960 Dr. C.H. Ketring |
| 1997-98 Tim Hankins | 1959 William E. Brawn |
| 1996-97 Bill Jokerst | 1958 Robert D. Lewis |
| 1995-96 Sue Evans | 1957 Herbert Boxdorfer |
| 1994-95 Gene Denman | 1956 Tom N. Edwards |
| 1993-94 David Taylor | 1955 Albert Karsch |
| 1992-93 Dan Bothe | 1954 Willard S. Rumburg |
| 1991-92 Ronald Stevens | 1953 Thomas P. Fitz |
| 1990-91 Mark Greishaber | 1952 John F. Spahr |
| 1989-90 Dr. Robert Huckstep | 1951 Howard C. Tetley |
| 1998-89 David Felske | 1950 Francis X. Stoll |
| 1987-88 Cliff Bell | 1949 B.F. Walter |
| 1986-87 Ronald J. Thomure | 1948 Dr. A.F. Mayerhoffer |
| 1985-86 Ronald G. Robinson Jr. | 1947 Rev. William T. Magill |
| 1984-85 William G. Murdick | 1945-46 Berl J. Miller |